Support the Podcast
Based on Good Strategy Bad Strategy: The Difference and Why It Matters by Richard Rumelt.
In the fourth quarter of 2023, Ipsos Kenya measured Citizen TV's market share at 39.68 percent of total television viewership. No competitor came close.
Twenty-four years earlier, the same station was off the air. The police had raided Royal Media Services and confiscated transmission equipment from Citizen TV and Radio Citizen. The shutdown followed an earlier closure in 2000, a year after launch.
The distance between a station that could be easily switched off and the most watched channel in the country was closed by a strategy with the shape Richard Rumelt describes in Good Strategy Bad Strategy: a diagnosis of the real obstacle, a guiding policy that ruled out the easy options, and coherent actions that reinforced each other for two decades. Here is that strategy in seven parts.
Every good strategy has three parts working as one unit. The diagnosis names the single most important challenge. The guiding policy decides how to meet that challenge by ruling out what the company will not do. The coherent actions are the specific moves that reinforce that policy. Remove any one part and what remains is not strategy.
Macharia's diagnosis was that Kenya Broadcasting Corporation held the only broadcasting licence ever issued in the country, and no regulator had a process for granting a second one. The obstacle was not capital or talent but the absence of any precedent for a private broadcaster to exist.
His guiding policy ruled out waiting for the government to legalise free press or design a licensing process. In an account Macharia gave publicly in 2025, he visited a government official named Makau, asked for a blank sheet of paper, and wrote his own licence approval: "This letter constitutes the only licence you require to broadcast private radio and television." Citizen TV then launched on that authority in 1999.
The coherent actions followed the same line for the next two decades. Macharia hired Julian Macharia, a communications professional, to build language-specific radio stations at a rate of three a year. The network grew from Radio Citizen in Swahili and Hot 96 in English into eleven additional stations, each carrying a single vernacular language all day. Every station reinforced the same aim: reach the Kenyan audience that English and Swahili broadcasting left out.
Some businesses are built so that every part depends on every other part, and the weakest link determines the strength of the whole. Once every link is brought to a high standard, the business is hard to copy, because a competitor must match every link at once, not just the most visible one.
Citizen TV does not generate its audience in isolation. Radio Citizen and the vernacular stations feed listeners toward Citizen TV's news bulletins and entertainment programming, while the Inooro brand runs as both a radio station and, since its television launch on 26 October 2015, a television station carrying the same Kikuyu-speaking audience across two formats. Advertisers buy bundled packages across the radio network and the television flagship rather than placements on a single platform.
A competitor entering with one strong television station, as Mediamax did with K24 in 2008, inherits none of this. K24's vernacular arm, Kameme TV and Kameme FM, covers a single language. To match Royal Media Services on equal terms, a new entrant would need a comparable radio network already built, language by language, county by county, a position that takes years and a sequence of regulatory approvals to assemble.
Having a competitive advantage is one thing. Keeping it is another. Isolating mechanisms are the specific frictions that stop a well-resourced competitor from copying what a company has built: licences, decades of brand reputation, switching costs, network effects. An advantage without an isolating mechanism is a head start, not a moat.
The clearest test of Royal Media Services' isolating mechanism came in 2014, when the...
Continue reading this playbook below